Necromancy
Jun. 10th, 2016 11:29 amYou know how sometimes you just wake up grumpy?
Today I woke up grumpy about necromancy always being considered automatically evil
when death spells of other colleges aren't.
( Read more... )
And yet 'charm' spells are 'good', and animating meat is evil?
They have their priorities so very backwards.
Of course they also have unhelpfully fuzzy definitions of good, evil, order and chaos, that don't match the working definitions in other books.
I was also thinking about how our definitions of evil are heavily shaped by our reproductive strategy. Mostly I think this when trying to figure out goa'uld, but, we have one child at a time and look after them intensively and for a long time, and we call that Good. But the goa'uld have thousands of spawn. If they picked one to look after for a long time then how would that be more Good? What is Good to a species with the exact opposite reproductive strategy? Probably something about the greatest good for the greatest number, personal is not the same as important, changing the whole feeding ground for the better rather than individually nurturing. Needs thinking through.
Or, possibly, I could find something useful and productive to do with my day.
Today I woke up grumpy about necromancy always being considered automatically evil
when death spells of other colleges aren't.
( Read more... )
And yet 'charm' spells are 'good', and animating meat is evil?
They have their priorities so very backwards.
Of course they also have unhelpfully fuzzy definitions of good, evil, order and chaos, that don't match the working definitions in other books.
I was also thinking about how our definitions of evil are heavily shaped by our reproductive strategy. Mostly I think this when trying to figure out goa'uld, but, we have one child at a time and look after them intensively and for a long time, and we call that Good. But the goa'uld have thousands of spawn. If they picked one to look after for a long time then how would that be more Good? What is Good to a species with the exact opposite reproductive strategy? Probably something about the greatest good for the greatest number, personal is not the same as important, changing the whole feeding ground for the better rather than individually nurturing. Needs thinking through.
Or, possibly, I could find something useful and productive to do with my day.