Stealing the good plots
Jul. 19th, 2008 04:22 pmSo I was talking about Doctor Who the other day and someone said that the big difference between classic and new series was the classic series ripped off everything and the new series only rips plots from the old.
Which I don't quite agree with, because if the classic series has already ripped everything then anything borrowed will look like it comes from Doctor Who already.
But.
I was thinking: Take plots from one series, apply them to characters from the other.
I'm mostly thinking Torchwood, because I mostly do.
And, say, Buffy. Because both I and the Torchwood writers like it.
The tricky part is to transfer the metaphor. Buffy is about high school and young adult life as hell, and the monsters, at their best, reflect some precise aspect of the experience. You could transfer Beer Bad to the Torchwood team - in fact please do, it could be bloody hilarious - but it would mean something rather different. For Buffy and Xander it was about latching on to this symbol of mature adulthood and trying to fit in with some idealised grown up social group. Team Torchwood... well, they've already been drinking for long enough the former really doesn't apply. The latter might. And makes me tempted to make it a Tosh story. Or, make it an Owen story post non-drinking because he'd get really wound up about possibility of drinking and if he then discovers a substance that duplicates the effects, well...
So, can be done. But requires alchemy.
Some of the plots are naturals for particular characters. It would be oh so easy to Marcie Ianto. Especially since if someone takes invisible people away for secret training in the Torchwood 'verse it should be Torchwood.
Xander's love spell meets Owen's aftershave quite neatly.
I can't currently think of much for Gwen to do. If I want to write proper Torchwood stories I'm going to have to rewatch with an eye to Gwen. Because really all I've noticed her bringing to the story thus far is whining about humanity and yet not being able to cope with it when she finds it. Which, actually, hello Angel? Maybe? Hmmm. ANYway, must pay attention to Gwen to write her properly.
Anyone else want to play?
Torchwood or Doctor Who characters, Buffy or Angel plots... who needs to meet what and why?
Which I don't quite agree with, because if the classic series has already ripped everything then anything borrowed will look like it comes from Doctor Who already.
But.
I was thinking: Take plots from one series, apply them to characters from the other.
I'm mostly thinking Torchwood, because I mostly do.
And, say, Buffy. Because both I and the Torchwood writers like it.
The tricky part is to transfer the metaphor. Buffy is about high school and young adult life as hell, and the monsters, at their best, reflect some precise aspect of the experience. You could transfer Beer Bad to the Torchwood team - in fact please do, it could be bloody hilarious - but it would mean something rather different. For Buffy and Xander it was about latching on to this symbol of mature adulthood and trying to fit in with some idealised grown up social group. Team Torchwood... well, they've already been drinking for long enough the former really doesn't apply. The latter might. And makes me tempted to make it a Tosh story. Or, make it an Owen story post non-drinking because he'd get really wound up about possibility of drinking and if he then discovers a substance that duplicates the effects, well...
So, can be done. But requires alchemy.
Some of the plots are naturals for particular characters. It would be oh so easy to Marcie Ianto. Especially since if someone takes invisible people away for secret training in the Torchwood 'verse it should be Torchwood.
Xander's love spell meets Owen's aftershave quite neatly.
I can't currently think of much for Gwen to do. If I want to write proper Torchwood stories I'm going to have to rewatch with an eye to Gwen. Because really all I've noticed her bringing to the story thus far is whining about humanity and yet not being able to cope with it when she finds it. Which, actually, hello Angel? Maybe? Hmmm. ANYway, must pay attention to Gwen to write her properly.
Anyone else want to play?
Torchwood or Doctor Who characters, Buffy or Angel plots... who needs to meet what and why?