Invader, CJ Cherryh
Dec. 11th, 2014 07:46 amI wasn't exactly enamoured of the first book in the Foreigner series, but I usually like the author, so I've bought more.
Bren is a stupidhead who spends most of his time apologising for being shot at. He makes things happen, but very seldom on purpose. And there's a whole lot of men around, even if the best character is someone's grandmother.
But okay, it's a long series and it's readable. Also I figure it's maybe like one of those series where he starts as an ensign? So maybe possibly he will be less stupid as he goes along?
I would say it would be difficult to be more stupid, except there's a character introduced in this one pretty much to demonstrate what more stupid looks like. Who is unfortunately a woman. A lot of the opposition are women, while current power is male. It's weird and slightly creepy. And quite a lot like a lot of Cherryh's other books. But then the vast majority of them are decades worth of time travel, being written across a long career, so, *shrugs*
Two books in, I'm still hoping it'll get good eventually. I've bought the third already though, so I'll read that too.
Cherryh's thing that she's good at is alien concepts that do not translate. People that stay fundamentally different even after you understand them. So you start out with a word that is crucial to the aliens but baffling to the humans, and the story demonstrates what it means. Aliens are wired different, and that matters. But they're not mono cultures, in this series especially, they also have cultural differences on top of the biological ones, so you get different ways the alien biological imperatives and impulses can play out.
It's just the narrator, on the whole, doesn't understand them, so there's a lot of blundering about making mistakes about it.
The hero of the series is a translator - the translator, the only one on the whole planet the treaty allows. And the untranslatables are key.
Hence looking like a stupidhead a lot.
This particular set of aliens don't have love or friendship. You can't say you like someone, it's the same word as liking a particular food and it sounds really conceptually weird to them. What they have is equally weird and mysterious to humans, including the point of view guy. He sort of blunders about trying to make friends and reminding himself there's no such thing and then still trying some more. Except then at the end whatever social connections he has managed to form end up working real well, so that's just... baffling and odd.
So I guess that's one why I don't precisely like these books. They're all about social bafflement and I can get that at home, so to speak.
But I keep on wanting to like them, because complex political thriller with aliens, and a lot of sequels, that sounds like my kind of fun. Just, so far, it's more of a way to fill in hours without it actively sucking. Which works, but, you know, I kind of keep trying to like it more.
Bren is a stupidhead who spends most of his time apologising for being shot at. He makes things happen, but very seldom on purpose. And there's a whole lot of men around, even if the best character is someone's grandmother.
But okay, it's a long series and it's readable. Also I figure it's maybe like one of those series where he starts as an ensign? So maybe possibly he will be less stupid as he goes along?
I would say it would be difficult to be more stupid, except there's a character introduced in this one pretty much to demonstrate what more stupid looks like. Who is unfortunately a woman. A lot of the opposition are women, while current power is male. It's weird and slightly creepy. And quite a lot like a lot of Cherryh's other books. But then the vast majority of them are decades worth of time travel, being written across a long career, so, *shrugs*
Two books in, I'm still hoping it'll get good eventually. I've bought the third already though, so I'll read that too.
Cherryh's thing that she's good at is alien concepts that do not translate. People that stay fundamentally different even after you understand them. So you start out with a word that is crucial to the aliens but baffling to the humans, and the story demonstrates what it means. Aliens are wired different, and that matters. But they're not mono cultures, in this series especially, they also have cultural differences on top of the biological ones, so you get different ways the alien biological imperatives and impulses can play out.
It's just the narrator, on the whole, doesn't understand them, so there's a lot of blundering about making mistakes about it.
The hero of the series is a translator - the translator, the only one on the whole planet the treaty allows. And the untranslatables are key.
Hence looking like a stupidhead a lot.
This particular set of aliens don't have love or friendship. You can't say you like someone, it's the same word as liking a particular food and it sounds really conceptually weird to them. What they have is equally weird and mysterious to humans, including the point of view guy. He sort of blunders about trying to make friends and reminding himself there's no such thing and then still trying some more. Except then at the end whatever social connections he has managed to form end up working real well, so that's just... baffling and odd.
So I guess that's one why I don't precisely like these books. They're all about social bafflement and I can get that at home, so to speak.
But I keep on wanting to like them, because complex political thriller with aliens, and a lot of sequels, that sounds like my kind of fun. Just, so far, it's more of a way to fill in hours without it actively sucking. Which works, but, you know, I kind of keep trying to like it more.