Different attitudes to Britain
Feb. 18th, 2012 06:13 pmI'm poking around at my story ideas some more and I have realised that, just by habit, I've spread between my half dozen characters all the attitudes to national identity I can think of. ( Read more... ) if I decide me being British is enough knowing to do all this, that's already decided a lot about the distinctiveness of all the parts. And yet I know I can't even get all the words right, and the politics is beyond me. If I were writing for television I'd fix it by getting writers from all the places, though since there's only half a dozen episodes in British TV that would mean giving half the episodes to people that weren't me. Or writing in a room and not having an episode each. I don't know. I'm not writing for TV anyway and can't recruit people.
I was going to say I don't even know what I'll do with all this, what impact it'll have on my characters. But I know some of it. Susan is going to want to set up an offworld colony. That's her mission, once she sees the possibility.
And I've been talking about the story as about a colony on another world, and when inspired by Atlantis fic I've liked the ones where Atlantis goes independent. But I'm thinking now, the Atlantis stories, are they usually with a very American view of independence? ( Read more... ) And if we're talking conflict over independence I have examples much closer to home. All those bits of the United Kingdom having a great big argument about independence all my life, and only bits of it with violence. Mostly it's with voting. Plus the idea that a colony is a very long journey away, that you have to go far away before you deal with Different, that I do not grok. It's the neighbours. You can walk there. Declaring independence is like putting up a really serious fence, or possibly growing leylandii. And we have, like, nested layers of political entity, like Wales is part of the UK is part of the European Union. Even one of the politics parties I just now read on wiki, the ones that want to leave the United Kingdom, they don't want to leave the European Union. But there's other parties that are all about staying the UK and leaving the EU. I don't know as America has so many layers. Being British is the middle layer in this argue. And then outside that there's the rest of the world, only with the Commonwealth we sort of sprawl all over it a bit. We stand in so many different relations to other countries, saying 'independence' gets so very complicated.
So if I'm going to write about an offworld colony with some leaders wanting complete independence from Earth, I'm not going to have a binary in mind, I'm not going to be all or nothing about it, and I'm really not going to just close the gate on them and say the old world doesn't matter any more. I'm going to be thinking how it fits with all this all, the already debated, multilayered complexities of UK politics.
( Read more... )
I was going to say I don't even know what I'll do with all this, what impact it'll have on my characters. But I know some of it. Susan is going to want to set up an offworld colony. That's her mission, once she sees the possibility.
And I've been talking about the story as about a colony on another world, and when inspired by Atlantis fic I've liked the ones where Atlantis goes independent. But I'm thinking now, the Atlantis stories, are they usually with a very American view of independence? ( Read more... ) And if we're talking conflict over independence I have examples much closer to home. All those bits of the United Kingdom having a great big argument about independence all my life, and only bits of it with violence. Mostly it's with voting. Plus the idea that a colony is a very long journey away, that you have to go far away before you deal with Different, that I do not grok. It's the neighbours. You can walk there. Declaring independence is like putting up a really serious fence, or possibly growing leylandii. And we have, like, nested layers of political entity, like Wales is part of the UK is part of the European Union. Even one of the politics parties I just now read on wiki, the ones that want to leave the United Kingdom, they don't want to leave the European Union. But there's other parties that are all about staying the UK and leaving the EU. I don't know as America has so many layers. Being British is the middle layer in this argue. And then outside that there's the rest of the world, only with the Commonwealth we sort of sprawl all over it a bit. We stand in so many different relations to other countries, saying 'independence' gets so very complicated.
So if I'm going to write about an offworld colony with some leaders wanting complete independence from Earth, I'm not going to have a binary in mind, I'm not going to be all or nothing about it, and I'm really not going to just close the gate on them and say the old world doesn't matter any more. I'm going to be thinking how it fits with all this all, the already debated, multilayered complexities of UK politics.
( Read more... )