Metaphors that feel more right
May. 19th, 2009 12:48 pmI just read a fic which, perfectly in character, had a character going to America thinking that men go west and then they go to the stars. Like, the immigrant American expansion is why humans eventually go to the stars, straight line.
And that feels wrong. Really, gut level, wrong.
Not just for the obvious - if we go out to the stars and find neighbours and treat them like they did the original inhabitants in far too many places I'm applying to be a new species.
But it's also not my history, and that's not my future. In that straight line I'm left way, way behind.
Space is like the sea, not the other shore. Like going out fishing. Some people take a boat out every morning, some of them go out for months, but it's going out somewhere actually empty of people and dreaming of mermaids and coming home again. I know space (probably) has a shortage of your actual fish. So maybe it's more like the mining platforms, going out there and going deep for what can't be found elsewhere. Or maybe we'll find better ways that don't run out, like the constant attempts to turn the waves into whatever power we need. Still, it's going out and staying a long while and missing home but making a new one with your crew, and coming home.
And maybe we'll find other shores full of other people, and maybe it'll be like it has been around here with those across the water, pretty much a long fight with intervals, though we're doing pretty good just lately. Maybe it'll be vikings to the stars or maybe it'll be privateers, or perhaps we'll try merchant adventuring.
But this is space to me, this is the next frontier, the one that rolls right up to our shores and we've always been dealing with on the edges.
I think about home, little island place where the sea feels important even if I haven't got around to seeing it since, hmmm, out the window at a Buffy convention I think, from the wrong side so the sun was backwards.
I think about America, which seems from here to be mostly made of earth, huge great going everywhere place.
I think about how metaphor is geographic.
And that feels wrong. Really, gut level, wrong.
Not just for the obvious - if we go out to the stars and find neighbours and treat them like they did the original inhabitants in far too many places I'm applying to be a new species.
But it's also not my history, and that's not my future. In that straight line I'm left way, way behind.
Space is like the sea, not the other shore. Like going out fishing. Some people take a boat out every morning, some of them go out for months, but it's going out somewhere actually empty of people and dreaming of mermaids and coming home again. I know space (probably) has a shortage of your actual fish. So maybe it's more like the mining platforms, going out there and going deep for what can't be found elsewhere. Or maybe we'll find better ways that don't run out, like the constant attempts to turn the waves into whatever power we need. Still, it's going out and staying a long while and missing home but making a new one with your crew, and coming home.
And maybe we'll find other shores full of other people, and maybe it'll be like it has been around here with those across the water, pretty much a long fight with intervals, though we're doing pretty good just lately. Maybe it'll be vikings to the stars or maybe it'll be privateers, or perhaps we'll try merchant adventuring.
But this is space to me, this is the next frontier, the one that rolls right up to our shores and we've always been dealing with on the edges.
I think about home, little island place where the sea feels important even if I haven't got around to seeing it since, hmmm, out the window at a Buffy convention I think, from the wrong side so the sun was backwards.
I think about America, which seems from here to be mostly made of earth, huge great going everywhere place.
I think about how metaphor is geographic.