(no subject)
Feb. 18th, 2007 09:54 amNewspapers make me *facepalm* often.
Articles that use the phrase "common sense dictates" as rebuttal to actual research are deeply stupid, because all common sense is made of is ideology you've forgotten you learned.
And asking if the playground is full of drunks - has she looked lately? Because I clearly recall classmates having ambulance level drink binges when *I* was in school, and subsequent research has shown the problem getting worse. And maybe they're not in the playground, but in my day it was only because they were in the pub across the street, so fuck knows why she thinks it's a good indicator. The answer is "yes, the drunks and the drug addicts and the pregnant teens and the mentally ill you're asking rhetorical questions about are there and your 'common sense' keeps your eyes closed to them". The report they're letting 'common sense' dictate to was meant to open their eyes. Surely when data meets 'common sense' it's *data* that should win?
This is why Sunnydale denial and its Torchwood equivalent seem to me both plausible, depressing, and actually important - because this shit goes on all the time but some people with a comfortable mind-world set up just ignore what doesn't fit.
This is also why Fortean is an important philosophical position.
Rocks fall from the sky! It just happened! Deal!
Articles that use the phrase "common sense dictates" as rebuttal to actual research are deeply stupid, because all common sense is made of is ideology you've forgotten you learned.
And asking if the playground is full of drunks - has she looked lately? Because I clearly recall classmates having ambulance level drink binges when *I* was in school, and subsequent research has shown the problem getting worse. And maybe they're not in the playground, but in my day it was only because they were in the pub across the street, so fuck knows why she thinks it's a good indicator. The answer is "yes, the drunks and the drug addicts and the pregnant teens and the mentally ill you're asking rhetorical questions about are there and your 'common sense' keeps your eyes closed to them". The report they're letting 'common sense' dictate to was meant to open their eyes. Surely when data meets 'common sense' it's *data* that should win?
This is why Sunnydale denial and its Torchwood equivalent seem to me both plausible, depressing, and actually important - because this shit goes on all the time but some people with a comfortable mind-world set up just ignore what doesn't fit.
This is also why Fortean is an important philosophical position.
Rocks fall from the sky! It just happened! Deal!