there's a thing in fantrhopology about
transgender issues, and why isn't there more ficme, one reason I like Ethan is the whole Change thing. Fluidity and possibility. Can be anything he wants. Can make everyone else be anything he wants. Nifty.
Could that include writing about sex swaps? Yeah.
But would that be a transgender story?
I haven't the slightest clue.
Seems to me that the word is about a community and a bunch of people with specific attitudes and stories and, really, I know not of this.
Can I understand not liking the body you're in? Oh so very. Can I understand not wanting to be female? Yup. How about wanting to try out being a guy? Oh yes.
But wanting to stay that way? Where's the fun in that?
great big comprehension gap.
staying the same means not-being half of things. why not be all things? Well, because they don't want to be, I guess. Still, this to me seems odd.
Also, while I can come up with reasons for people wanting to switch sex in the Buffyverse, they are not reasons which seem to match reasons RL people would have.
Slayers are always female. So if someone didn't want to be a Slayer they could get that Hecate spell done and be male. Presto, no more problem.
Or, Slayers are always female. Watchers are raised being told that Slayers are the only ones strong enough. Wouldn't you want to be strong enough? And if strong=female, wanting to be female seems logical.
Or then there's Andrew. I can see Andrew wanting to be a girl. Guys date girls and its All Okay. And also, girls kick ass. But I can't see it being healthy if Andrew wants to be a girl, because on Andrew it would be a symptom of his general problem with identity. Getting comfy as a guy would be progress.
Though I keep on fic bunnying him into dresses for Halloween. There's something about Andrew in ruby slippers... Or, an Andrew who learns about Slayers early on dressing up as one. Like, it could even be a secret costume, just trousers and t-shirt and a stake, but Andrew knows that he's a Slayer really so when the spell goes into effect, changes.
Also, there's the punchline to a fic joke I never finished writing. Ethan captured by the initiative promises to change someone into something every soldier fears. So he makes him a crossdressing queer.
I, er, stopped writing it because I realised that might only be funny in my head...
change character X into opposite sex, sit back, and watch, is not a transgender story really. Its a thing to do to someone, it isn't about their wanting to anything. It is usually actually opposite of trans, since the fix at the end is the restoration of the status quo.
also there are weaknesses in how it is often written - character X swaps personalities along with their genitals. Which, to me, seems unlikely. Though I can certainly see them changing moods. Hormones are strange.
Halloween episode stories though I do feel would involve some sex swaps. In school in my year there were always the same guys who did drag for free clothes day (all in my art class). I kind of thought there was always those guys. And I'm entirely sure Ethan would be happy to encourage them.
But then again 'Fear Itself' stories could involve some sex swap too, because it would be pretty scary suddenly having the wrong bits. Or, like when Xander broke into the frat house, got to wear the funny girl stuff for humiliation, there would be guys who would have that as their fear, that being real and not temporary.
But that certainly wouldn't be a pleasant story.
Or, again, about transgender precisely.